I consider myself someone who judges films rather harshly. I feel like most of the people who are bashing this film are people who went into the theater close minded and not even willing to give this film a chance. I’m not a fan of Single White Female, as I found every single one of the characters to get on my last nerve. I’m not saying they’re acting was bad, I’m saying that I didn’t think the characters were likable.
The Roommate is a fresh take on Single White Female. I liked the college setting better than the apartment setting because it gave Sara and the viewer a more confined feeling. In an apartment there are doors you can lock and places to hide, whereas in a dorm room there’s you and there’s the psycho.
Leighton Meester’s performance of Rebecca was very good. She did a really good job of portraying the psycho. And a lot of people are bashing Minka Kelly for her portrayal of Sara and to be honest Leighton did outshine her, only because the character of Rebecca is much more complex and interesting. Sara isn’t supposed to be an interesting character. She’s a typical college girl who doesn’t have much of a back story because she doesn’t really need a backstory. We’re introduced to Sara as a college freshman who drinks, cusses, and has sex just like the next college freshman on film, but somehow Rebecca sees something in her she wants and will do anything to get.
I appreciated that they didn’t just make Rebecca a psycho and left it at that, then I would have been angry, but I think they spent a perfect amount of time explaining Rebecca and her past. We don’t know the specifics on Maria because we don’t need to, she has two minutes of screen time and in that two minutes of screen time we see that whatever happened between her and Rebecca it definitely left her scarred.
I liked that other than Rebecca and Sara we didn’t have a lot of interaction between other characters and that’s the way it should’ve been, as that was Rebecca’s goal. She wanted to isolate Sara and by doing that, isolating the viewers.
It’s not a horror film. Not at all. Not at all. Not at all. It does have its scares and jump scenes and is filled to the brim with chilling moments though. And a part of me even agrees with those are saying it should have been a TV movie. I think it would have been judged a bit more fairly. But I have to say believe it or not, unlike most Screen Gems it does have depth.
Watch it once. And then watch it again. And THEN make your final judgement because in my opinion most of the people that are insulting the writers/actors/director are just stubborn SWF fans.
My rating 8/10. For a fun, creepy thriller with good acting and a pretty good story.
By prince9111995 from United States (IMDB)
rebecca lossin